Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1.1.2027 - City of Rexburg - Renewal V4 Final VersionComparison of Benefits AJ Argyle Employee Benefits Broker aj.argyle@gbsbenefits.com (208) 529-3541 Magen Smith Account Manager magen.smith@gbsbenefits.com (208) 529-3541 Prep: gc January 2027 Renewal City of Rexburg Carrier(s)Plan Year Monthly Premium Annual Premium Percent Increase Current $222,919 $2,675,028 Proposed Renewal $296,486 $3,557,826 Current $14,451 $173,415 Proposed Renewal $16,908 $202,900 Current $3,336 $40,029 Proposed Renewal $3,336 $40,029 Current $1,682 $20,188 Proposed Renewal $1,413 $16,953 Current $2,153 $25,838 Proposed Renewal $1,723 $20,670 $244,541 $2,934,498 $319,866 $3,838,378 Change from Current $75,325 $903,880 City of Rexburg Annual Renewal Summary Life MetLife Medical SelectHealth 33.00% Dental MetLife 17.00% Vision MetLife 0.00% -16.02% Totals MetLife 30.80% LTD -20.00% Benefits illustrated in summary for comparison purposes only. Please refer to the carrier plan document for further plan details. Page 2 10/13/2026 Comparison of Benefits Medical Carrier Option Funding Type Monthly Premium Annual Premium Annual Increase Percent Increase SelectHealth CURRENT Fully Insured $222,919 $2,675,028 ---- SelectHealth RENEWAL Fully Insured $296,486 $3,557,826 $882,798 33.00% Regence QUOTE-1 Fully Insured $349,986 $4,199,831 $1,524,803 57.00% BC of ID QUOTE-2 Fully Insured $297,017 $3,564,199 $889,171 33.24% BC of ID QUOTE-3 Fully Insured $298,837 $3,586,040 $911,012 34.06% BC of ID QUOTE-4 Fully Insured $325,854 $3,910,252 $1,235,224 46.18% *Reminder: Fees will apply for HSA bank account vendors. This information is based on census information at the time of quoting. Subsequent enrollment changes may not be reflected and are not expected to materially impact plan comparisons City of Rexburg Medical Summary Benefits illustrated are for comparison purposes only. Please refer to carrier plan documents for further details. In case of discrepancy, carrier plan documents and rates will prevail. Page 4 10/13/2026 System Facility Ch o i c e N e t w o r k (P P O ) SL H P ( C C O ) Pr e f e r r e d Re g e n c e A c c o r d St . L u k e ' s ( S L H P ) Br i g h t P a t h Me d Sa i n t A l p h o n s u s (S A H A ) Benewah Community Hospital X X X X Bonner General Hospital X X X X Shoshone Medical Center (West Shoshone Hosp District)X X X X X Syringa General Hospital X X X X Boundary Community Hospital X X X Kootenai Health X X X Clearwater Valley X X X Northern Idaho Advanced Care Hospital X X X Rehabilitation Hospital of the Northwest X X St. Mary's Hospital X X X Gritman Medical Center X X X St. Joseph Regional X X X Northwest Specialty Hospital X X X West Valley Medical Center X X X X X Cassia Regional Hospital X X X X X X Treasure Valley Hospital X X X Saint Alphonsus Regional Medical Center X X X X Saint Alphonsus Medical Center Nampa X X X X Saint Alphonsus Medical Center Baker City X X Saint Alphonsus Medical Center Ontario X X Saint Alphonsus Regional Rehab Hosp (Encompass Health)X X X X St. Luke's McCall LTD X X X X St. Luke's Regional Medical Center LTD X X X X St. Luke's Nampa Medical Center X X X X St. Luke's Elmore Medical Center X X X X St. Luke's Jerome Medical Center X X X X St. Luke's Magic Valley Regional Medical Ceneter X X X X St. Luke's Wood River X X X X North Canyon Medical Center X X X X X X Cascade Medical Center Hospital Distict X X X X X X Cottonwood Creek Behavioral Hospital X X X BHC Intermountain Hospital X X X Lifeways Hospital X X X Steele Memorial Medical Center X X X X X Minidoka Memorial Hospital X X X X X X Memorial Hospital (Weiser Valley Hospital District)X X X X X X X Vibra Hospital of Boise X X Valor Health - Walter Knox Memorial Hospital X X X X X X X Bear Lake Memorial Hospital X X X X X Bingham Memorial Hospital X X X X X Grove Creek Medical Center X X X X X Caribou Memorial Hospital X X X X X Eastern Idaho Regional Medical Center - EIRMC X X X X Franklin County Medical Center X X X X X Lost Rivers Medical Center X X X X X Madison Memorial Hospital X X X X X Nell J Redfield Memorial Hospital X X X Oneida County Hospital X X Portneuf Medical Center X X X X X Power County Hospital District X X X X X Teton Valley Health Care X X X X X Mountain View Hospital X X X X Idaho Falls Community Hospital X X X X Total 49 13 52 39 15 16 23 9 Network information is for illustrative purposes only and is subject to change. Please refer to carrier documents for further details. Idaho Carrier Network Comparison Blue Cross of Idaho Regence BlueShield of ID Select Health *Moda Health not available in Twin Falls, Jerome, or Gooding Counties Re g i o n 1 Re g i o n 2 Re g i o n 3 *UHC Navigator network not available in ID SelectHealthMed 70% $2,500 Trad-1SelectHealthMed 70% $2,500 Trad-2SelectHealthMed 70% $2,500 Trad-3RENEWALSelectHealthMed 70% $2,500 Trad-1RENEWALSelectHealthMed 70% $2,500 Trad-2RENEWALSelectHealthMed 70% $2,500 Trad-3 In/Out In-Network Out-of-Network In-Network Out-of-Network Deductible $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 Out of Pocket Maximum $4,500/$9,000 $6,500/$13,000 $4,500/$9,000 $6,500/$13,000 Deductible Embedded OOP Max Embedded Primary Care Physicians $20 50% AD $20 50% AD Specialists $40 50% AD $40 50% AD Mental Health & Chemical Dependency $20 50% AD $20 50% AD Urgent Care $20 50% AD $20 50% AD Emergency Room Minor Lab / X-Ray 0%50% AD 0%50% AD Major Lab / X-Ray 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Hospital Outpatient Surgery 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Preventive Care 0%50% AD 0%50% AD Inp Hospital / Physicians 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Inp Maternity 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Chiropractic/Manipulations $20 (20 vis/yr)50% AD (20 vis/yr)$20 (20 vis/yr)50% AD (20 vis/yr) Adult Routine Eye Exam $40 50% AD $40 50% AD Rx Deductible Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Mail Order Monthly Rates Subs Enrollment Tier Subscribers Subscribers 20 Employee 20 20 29 Employee + Spouse 29 29 2 Employee + Child 2 2 3 Employee + Children 3 3 65 Family 65 65 119 TOTAL BY PLAN 119 119 Percent of Increase $300 then 30% AD $300 then 30% AD 33.00% $222,919 $296,486 $2,480.20 $3,298.70 CURRENT RENEWAL Yes Yes $50 AD $50 AD 30% AD 30% AD Re t a i l Prescription Drugs (In-Network) $500 $500 $10 $10 $10/$60 AD/$150 AD $10/$60 AD/$150 AD $100 AD Of f i c e Vi s i t s Inpatient Services Additional Benefits Employee Navigator Compatibility City of Rexburg Medical Comparison Yes Yes Yes Yes Professional Services SelectHealth SelectHealth Med 70% $2,500 Trad Med 70% $2,500 Trad $100 AD Premium Rate Premium Rate Fully Insured Fully Insured $2,145.80 $2,853.90 $1,191.30 $1,584.40 $1,356.00 $1,803.50 $678.10 $901.90 Medical Benefits Benefits illustrated are for comparison purposes only. Please refer to carrier plan documents for further details. In case of discrepancy, carrier plan documents and rates will prevail. Page 6 10/13/2026 QUOTE-1RegenceClassic Preferred 70% $2,500 Trad-1QUOTE-1RegenceClassic Preferred 70% $2,500 Trad-2QUOTE-1RegenceClassic Preferred 70% $2,500 Trad-3QUOTE-2BC of IDCCO-MVN 70% $2,500 Trad-1QUOTE-2BC of IDCCO-MVN 70% $2,500 Trad-2QUOTE-2BC of IDCCO-MVN 70% $2,500 Trad-3QUOTE-3BC of IDCCO-PQA 70% $2,500 Trad-1QUOTE-3BC of IDCCO-PQA 70% $2,500 Trad-2QUOTE-3BC of IDCCO-PQA 70% $2,500 Trad-3QUOTE-4BC of IDPreferred Blue PPO 70% $2,500 Trad-1QUOTE-4BC of IDPreferred Blue PPO 70% $2,500 Trad-2QUOTE-4BC of IDPreferred Blue PPO 70% $2,500 Trad-3 In/Out In-Network Out-of-Network In-Network Out-of-Network In-Network Out-of-Network In-Network Out-of-Network Deductible $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 $2,500/$5,000 Out of Pocket Maximum $4,500/$9,000 $6,500/$13,000 $4,500/$9,000 $6,500/$13,000 $4,500/$9,000 $6,500/$13,000 $4,500/$9,000 $6,500/$13,000 Deductible Embedded OOP Max Embedded Primary Care Physicians $20 50% AD $0 50% AD $0 50% AD $0 50% AD Specialists $40 50% AD $40 50% AD $40 50% AD $40 50% AD Mental Health & Chemical Dependency $20 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Urgent Care $40 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Emergency Room 30% AD 30% AD 30% AD 30% AD 30% AD 30% AD Minor Lab / X-Ray 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Major Lab / X-Ray 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Hospital Outpatient Surgery 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Preventive Care 0%50% AD 0%50% AD 0%50% AD 0%50% AD Inp Hospital / Physicians 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Inp Maternity 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD 30% AD 50% AD Chiropractic/Manipulations 30% AD (20 vis/yr) 50% AD (20 vis/yr)See Plan Doc See Plan Doc See Plan Doc See Plan Doc See Plan Doc See Plan Doc Adult Routine Eye Exam Not Covered Not Covered See Plan Doc See Plan Doc See Plan Doc See Plan Doc See Plan Doc See Plan Doc Rx Deductible Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Mail Order Monthly Rates Subs Enrollment Tier Subscribers Subscribers Subscribers Subscribers 20 Employee 20 20 20 20 29 Employee + Spouse 29 29 29 29 2 Employee + Child 2 2 2 2 3 Employee + Children 3 3 3 3 65 Family 65 65 65 65 119 TOTAL BY PLAN 119 119 119 119 Percent of Increase 57.00%33.24%34.06%46.18% $349,986 $297,017 $298,837 $325,854 $3,562.50 $3,304.61 $3,324.86 $3,625.46 $2,652.10 $2,859.06 $2,876.58 $3,136.64 $1,916.20 $1,587.29 $1,597.01 $1,741.39 $2,706.30 $1,806.73 $1,817.80 $1,982.15 $1,407.60 $903.50 $909.04 $991.22 Premium Rate Premium Rate Premium Rate Premium Rate Fully Insured Fully Insured Fully Insured Fully Insured QUOTE-1 QUOTE-2 QUOTE-3 QUOTE-4 $30/$105 AD/$150 AD N/A N/A N/A $100 AD N/A N/A N/A $50 AD $50 $50 $50 $35 AD $30 $30 $30 Re t a i l $500 $500 $500 $500 Prescription Drugs (In-Network) $10 $10 $10 $10 Additional Benefits Professional Services City of Rexburg Medical Comparison Regence BC of ID BC of ID BC of ID Classic Preferred 70% $2,500 Trad CCO-MVN 70% $2,500 Trad CCO-PQA 70% $2,500 Trad Preferred Blue PPO 70% $2,500 Trad Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Employee Navigator Compatibility -------- Of f i c e Vi s i t s Inpatient Services $300 then 30% AD Medical Benefits Benefits illustrated are for comparison purposes only. Please refer to carrier plan documents for further details. In case of discrepancy, carrier plan documents and rates will prevail. Page 7 10/13/2026 Comparison of BenefitsDental Carrier Option Funding Type Monthly Premium Annual Premium Annual Increase Percent Increase MetLife CURRENT Fully Insured $14,451 $173,415 ---- MetLife RENEWAL Fully Insured $17,197 $206,366 $32,951 19.00% MetLife REVISED RENEWAL Fully Insured $16,908 $202,900 $29,485 17.00% This information is based on census information at the time of quoting. Subsequent enrollment changes may not be reflected and are not expected to materially impact plan comparisons City of Rexburg Dental Summary Benefits illustrated are for comparison purposes only. Please refer to carrier plan documents for further details. In case of discrepancy, carrier plan documents and rates will prevail. Page 9 10/13/2026 MetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-1MetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-2MetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-3RENEWALMetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-1RENEWALMetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-2RENEWALMetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-3REVISED RENEWALMetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-1REVISED RENEWALMetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-2REVISED RENEWALMetLifeMetLifeDental PPO $2,000-3 In/Out In-Network Out-of-Network In-Network Out-of-Network In-Network Out-of-Network Deductible $50/$150 $50/$150 $50/$150 $50/$150 $50/$150 $50/$150 Annual Maximum Preventive / Diagnostic 100%80%100%80%100%80% Basic 80%70%80%70%80%70% Major 50%40%50%40%50%40% Oral Surgery 80%70%80%70%80%70% Periodontics 80%70%80%70%80%70% Endodontics 80%70%80%70%80%70% Implants 50%40%50%40%50%40% Deductible Lifetime Maximum Child (under 19)50%50%50%50%50%50% Adult 50%50%50%50%50%50% Preventive Basic Major Orthodontics UCR Percentile Voluntary / Employer Paid Participation Requirements Rate Guarantee Monthly Rates Plan Type Subs Enrollment Tier Subscribers Subscribers Subscribers 17 Employee 17 17 17 34 Employee + Spouse 34 34 34 5 Employee + Child(ren)5 5 5 66 Family 66 66 66 122 TOTAL BY PLAN 122 122 122 Percent of Increase 19.00%17.00% $14,451 $17,197 $16,908 $36.11 $42.97 $164.10 $195.28 $192.00 Premium Rate Premium Rate $130.03 $84.35 $111.14 $132.26 $72.09 $85.79 $42.25 Premium Rate CURRENT Dental PPO $2,000 Fully Insured Dental PPO $2,000 Dental PPO $2,000 Fully Insured Fully Insured RENEWAL REVISED RENEWAL Employer Paid Employer Paid 12/31/2027 Greater of 10 or 79% 12/31/2026 12/31/2027 Greater of 10 or 79%Greater of 10 or 79% Employer Paid Orthodontics None $2,000 Waiting Periods MetLife City of Rexburg Dental Comparison MetLife None $2,000 Employee Navigator Compatibility YesYesYes None None None MetLife MetLife MetLife MetLife None None $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 None None None None Fee Schedule Fee Schedule None None None None Fee Schedule Dental Benefits Benefits illustrated are for comparison purposes only. Please refer to carrier plan documents for further details. In case of discrepancy, carrier plan documents and rates will prevail. Page 10 10/13/2026 Comparison of BenefitsVision Carrier Option Funding Type Monthly Premium Annual Premium Annual Increase Percent Increase MetLife CURRENT Fully Insured $3,336 $40,029 ---- MetLife RENEWAL Fully Insured $3,469 $41,627 $1,598 3.99% MetLife REVISED RENEWAL Fully Insured $3,336 $40,029 $0 0.00% This information is based on census information at the time of quoting. Subsequent enrollment changes may not be reflected and are not expected to materially impact plan comparisons City of Rexburg Vision Summary Benefits illustrated are for comparison purposes only. Please refer to carrier plan documents for further details. In case of discrepancy, carrier plan documents and rates will prevail. Page 12 10/13/2026 MetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-1CURRENTMetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-2CURRENTMetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-3RENEWALMetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-1RENEWALMetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-2RENEWALMetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-3REVISED RENEWALMetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-1REVISED RENEWALMetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-2REVISED RENEWALMetLifeMetLife - Superior NetworkSuperior Vision-3 In/Out In-Network Out-of-Network In-Network Out-of-Network In-Network Out-of-Network Eye Examination $0 Copay up to $45 $0 Copay up to $45 $0 Copay up to $45 Standard Plastic Lenses Single Vision $0 Copay up to $30 $0 Copay up to $30 $0 Copay up to $30 Bifocal $0 Copay up to $50 $0 Copay up to $50 $0 Copay up to $50 Trifocal $0 Copay up to $65 $0 Copay up to $65 $0 Copay up to $65 Frames*up to $200 then 20% off up to $70 up to $200 then 20% off up to $70 up to $200 then 20% off up to $70 Contact Lenses* Conventional up to $200 up to $105 up to $200 up to $105 up to $200 up to $105 Disposable up to $200 up to $105 up to $200 up to $105 up to $200 up to $105 *Frames or Contact Lenses Retail Chains (Frame allowance may vary) Costco Sam's/Walmart Target Visionworks Frequency Exams Lenses Frames Contacts Voluntary / Employer Paid Participation Requirements Rate Guarantee Monthly Rates Plan Type Subs Enrollment Tier Subscribers Subscribers Subscribers 20 Employee 20 20 20 31 Employee + Spouse 31 31 31 6 Employee + Child(ren)6 6 6 75 Family 75 75 75 132 TOTAL BY PLAN 132 132 132 Percent of Increase 3.99%0.00% $3,336 $3,469 $3,336 $31.82 $33.09 $31.82 $20.02 $20.82 $20.02 $20.23 $21.04 $20.23 $10.10 $10.50 $10.10 Premium Rate Premium Rate Premium Rate Superior Vision Superior Vision Superior Vision Fully Insured Fully Insured Fully Insured 12/31/2026 12/31/2027 12/31/2027 CURRENT RENEWAL REVISED RENEWAL --- Voluntary Voluntary Voluntary 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months 12 Months Included Included Included Included Included Included Included Included Included City of Rexburg Vision Comparison MetLife MetLife MetLife MetLife - Superior Network MetLife - Superior Network MetLife - Superior Network Employee Navigator Compatibility Yes Yes Yes Included Included Included Vision Benefits Benefits illustrated are for comparison purposes only. Please refer to carrier plan documents for further details. In case of discrepancy, carrier plan documents and rates will prevail. Page 13 10/13/2026 Comparison of BenefitsLife, AD&D, and Dependent Life All Full-Time X X X All Full-Time Who Elect Management Number of Eligible Employees 177 177 177 Eligible Employees with Family Status 161 161 161 $7,487,500 $7,487,500 $7,487,500 12/31/2026 12/31/2027 12/31/2027 Benefit Life Insurance $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 AD&D Insurance $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 Conversion Included Included Included Portability Included Included Included Dependent Life Spouse $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 Child (birth - 14 days)--- Child (14 days - 6 months)$100 $100 $100 Child (6 months - 19 years)$5,000 $5,000 $5,000 Monthly Rates CURRENT RENEWAL REVISED RENEWAL Basic Life (per $1,000)$0.178 $0.178 $0.142 AD&D (per $1,000)$0.020 $0.020 $0.020 Dependent Life $1.241 $1.241 $1.241 MONTHLY TOTAL $1,682 $1,682 $1,413 ANNUAL TOTAL $20,188 $20,188 $16,953 Percent of Increase 0.00%-16.02% Benefit Volume City of Rexburg Basic Life, AD&D and Dependent Life Comparison El i g i b i l i t y Rate Guarantee MetLife Benefits illustrated in summary for comparison purposes only. Please refer to the carrier plan document for further plan details. Page 15 10/13/2026 Increments Minimum Benefit Maximum Benefit Increments Minimum Benefit Maximum Benefit Increments Maximum Benefit -Birth to 14 days -14 days to 6 mths -6 mths to 19 yrs Employee Spouse Waiver of Premium Conversion Portability Participation Required Rate Guarantee Rates Per $1,000 Employee Spouse Employee Spouse <25 $0.081 $0.081 $0.081 $0.081 25-29 $0.081 $0.081 $0.081 $0.081 30-34 $0.086 $0.086 $0.086 $0.086 35-39 $0.111 $0.111 $0.111 $0.111 40-44 $0.159 $0.159 $0.159 $0.159 45-49 $0.220 $0.220 $0.220 $0.220 50-54 $0.358 $0.358 $0.358 $0.358 55-59 $0.547 $0.547 $0.547 $0.547 60-64 $0.811 $0.811 $0.811 $0.811 65-69 $1.333 $1.333 $1.333 $1.333 70-74 $2.142 $2.142 $2.142 $2.142 75+$2.142 $2.142 $2.142 $2.142 $0.021 MetLife $1,000, $2,000, $4,000, $5,000, $10,000 $100,000 - $1,000 $10,000 $500,000 $0.240 per $1,000 50% of EE $5,000 $5,000 $250,000 Employee Benefit Spouse Benefit 5x Salary $10,000 $10,000 RENEWAL $0.240 per $1,000 $0.021 $0.021 $0.021 $0.021 $25,000 Spouse Included Greater of 10 or 25% Included Included 12/31/2027 City of Rexburg Supplemental Life Guarantee Issue Additional Benefits Child Voluntary AD&D Dependent Rates Employee 5x Salary $10,000 $10,000 $500,000 50% of EE $5,000 $25,000 $100,000 $5,000 $250,000 $1,000, $2,000, $4,000, $5,000, $10,000 - $1,000 $10,000 Child Benefit Included Greater of 10 or 25% Included Included $0.021 CURRENT 12/31/2026 Benefits illustrated in summary for comparison purposes only. Please refer to the carrier plan document for further plan details. Page 16 10/13/2026 Comparison of Benefits Disability All Full-Time X X X All Full-Time Who Elect Management Number of Eligible Employees 177 177 177 Monthly Covered Payroll $861,252 $861,252 $861,252 Benefit Elimination Period 90 Days 90 Days 90 Days Benefit Percentage 50%50%50% Maximum Monthly Benefit $4,500 $4,500 $4,500 Duration of Benefit SSNRA SSNRA SSNRA Definition of Disability 24 Mo Own Occ 24 Mo Own Occ 24 Mo Own Occ 100%100%100% 100%100%100% 12/31/2026 12/31/2027 12/31/2027 Rates CURRENT RENEWAL REVISED RENEWAL Per $100 of Covered Payroll $0.250 $0.250 $0.200 MONTHLY TOTAL $2,153 $2,153 $1,723 ANNUAL TOTAL $25,838 $25,838 $20,670 Percent of Increase 0.00%-20.00% Rate Guarantee City of Rexburg Long Term Disability El i g i b i l i t y Employer Contribution Participation Required MetLife Benefits illustrated in summary for comparison purposes only. Please refer to the carrier plan document for further plan details. Page 18 10/13/2026