HomeMy WebLinkAboutPLAN REVIEW - 08-00335 - Madison High Schoolrk,
Findingsfor:
Madison High School
"Building a Safer Idaho"
Page 1 of 9
n
State of Idaho
D ivision of Building Safety
I 09U East Watertown Street, Suite- 1 20
Meridian, ID 83642
208.334.3950
Fax 208.855.9399
dbs.idaho.gov
Plan Review Findings
TO: JRW & Assoc iates
Date: 18 June 2008
PA#: SC 1295
Project; Madison Hi9� Scho.--%,
Occupancy Classification-.
Type of Construction;
Fire Sprinkler System
v ��a a. �,awrw�ra,�+WWv.{wuV.iv.,.t+fiA^ eTyyT14�.
E
11-6
T es, for area increase
The following is based on the 2006 IBC, I ECCY 2006 IRC, Parts I, II, III, IV, 2003 IRC V, VI ,
2003 IMC, IFGC, 2003 UPC, 2005 NEC and other codes as noted.
Building Code Plan Review Findin!gs-
Reviewed by: Arlan Smith 332�7123 (asmith@dbs-idaho.gov)
Additional information or corre�ctivns r+�qu� red
1 Thin ninrte pro r„ -.t I�,.,.-
- - - - -�-.._ �. - . •�--�-u��� ���l ! I#� �U �� « U ptunny in me Tire wall at corridor at grid dine 5 an
the first floor. The door �s unmarked on the floor pian. The section drawing refers to
specification Q8331 .A!. That specification section specifies a one-hour fire-raterd overhead
caning door. A 90 minute rating is required. The swinging section of the door needs swan
in the direction of exit travel from the west wing and be egt�ipped vuith panic hardware. �
Please submit details. CIBC 705.4]
2. The fire wall at grid line 5 is tO comply with TQC Section X05.5. 1. "Where the fire walk
intersects the exterior walls, the fire -re s i stance rating for the exterior wars on both sides of
the fire wall shad have a 1-h 0 tire-resin#ante rating with 314 -hour opening protection
where opening protection is required. The fire-resisfiance rating of the exterior wail shat!
extend a minimum of 4 feet (1220 mm) ach side of the intersection of the firewall to
exterior wail." Submit informa�iQn showing cor�plianc�. The windows in these corners do
not comply.
3. The doors in the dire walk on grid fine 5 in the corridors need to swing in the direction of exit
travel from the west wing (708A & 1 -St fl unmarked door). As submitted this will create
dead end corridors in violation of SBC Section 1+D1 7.3.
4. Door 708A is required to be at feast a 90 minute fire door and be automatic cnlas�or self
closing. [113C715-4) 9
5. Window FSR in fire will: Windows are not permitted in fire walls unless the la�i� system
complies with 113C Section 715.2. This means that the gIazin� systems wouldpassk�jthe
m
same tests as what as required fora 2 hour wall. [113C 715*5] �
"Building a Safer Idaho "
Paget of
6. Rooms 617 and 618 are each required to have at leasttwo exit accesses out. If doors are
installed they are to have panic hardware. Exit signs are also required. [IBC 1008.1.9,
10111.1, 1014.3, 1015.1]
7. The door hardware schedule in the submitted specification is not complete. Each door in a
means of egress from an occupancy of Group E having an occupant load of 50 or more
shall not be provided with a latch or lock unless it is panic hardware or fire exit hardware.
This would include.hardware groups: 1, 1 A, 1 B, 2, 33 5, 6, 77 1 0, 11, 12, 22, 23, 25 29 38,
42, 46, 47. [IBC 1008..1.9]1 ,
8, Firs doors shall be self-closing or automatic -closing in accordance with NFPA 80 or IBC
?'#x.4.7.
9. An accessible rou#e to rooms E30, E31 and E32 is required. [IBC 1104.4]
10- Auditorium aisle stairs: tread depths sha
have dimensional uniformity. The teleran
0.188 inch (4.$ mm), [IBC1025.11.1]
11 be a minimum of 11 inches (2i9 mm) and shall
Fce between adjacent dreads shall not exceed
'i
1. Auditorium aisle stairs: aisle stars steall be provided with handrails located either at the side
or within the aisle width. CIBC 1025.131
12. The auditorium seating, aisle widths, row spacing, cross aisles and other seating and exit
features are required to comply with SBC Section 1 Q�5. Please submit information to
sufficient detail for the determination of compliance. This would include at least: aisle
widths, raw spacing, sea
t widths, seal self rising, stair triad and riser dimensions, handrail
details, stair tread markings.
'(3. Rigid Cellular Polystyrene Geofoam Blocks are req�ired to separated from the inferior of
the building bll� a thermal barrier as per IBC ��03.4 or comply with IBC 26U3.9. Submit
information shovvi�g carr�pliance.
14. The sage emergency smoke vents shall comply with ABG 410.37. Please submit
information showing compliance.
15. Approximately 11 accessible wheel cha
submit information showing compliance
ir spaces are required in the auditorium. Please
with ABG 1108 ZW02. I.
16. Verify that drinking fountains are provided in the quantity required by SBC Chapter 29.
17. The exit sign at the roll down fire shutter in roam 50'I cornrnvns wig1 be directingeo Ie to a
door' they can not exit throuh in tie shutter closes. Delete the exit sign gar pro ds swinging
to
doors. PBC 1011.1, 1008.1%.2] 9 J
18. Suspended acoustical ceiling systems shah be instalIed in accordar�ce w�fih the provisions
of ASTM C 635, ASTM C 636 and the structural requirements in 1E3C Ch pter 16 and ASCE
7 section 13.5.G. Ceiling engineering done by the manufacturer end �ncarporated into their
"Building a Safer Idaho"
Page 3 of
installations instructions is acceptable. For seismic design cote o D
more stringent requirements in ASCE 7. �1BC 803.9.1.13 161111g� �he�e aye some
speei��cation to UBC Standard 25-2 o€� the ClSCA Standard� The reference in the
is outdated and no longer valid
for building code application.
19 -Vo -Tech Building: The Provisions of Section 416 shah appy to the c�nstructFon
installation and use of buildin�s and stru�tur�s, or P rts thereof, or the sprayingvf
ffammable pains, varnishes and lacquers ar other flammabie ma#erials or mixtes
or
compounds used for Painting, Varnishing, staining or similar purposes. Such construction
and equipment shall comply with Intemational Fire Code Section 1504. Spray finishing
operations conducted in buildings used dor Group, E occupancies shall be located in a spray
room protected with an approved automatic sprinkler system installed in; accordance with y
Section 903.3.1 .1 and separated verticaliy� and ho�-�zonta�ly from other areas by one- hour
dire barriers (IBC 416.2). Submit information showing compliance.
20- Provide visual fire alarm notification devices in a
room E06, the rooms in schedule C. [IBC 9x7'.9
21. Room E09: Where sinks are provided at least
[IBC 1109.3, see ICC A1 97.1 section 606]
�I public or common use areas including
5% but not fess than one is to be aceessibl.
22. Provide exit signs compl�ring with SBC Section 10 1 1. 1 at the exit access doors and the stair
from the upper level of the mein gym.
23. Submit energy code compliance reports for the Vo -Tech building. [IECC1 04j
�-
- ....-.sem -." � '"'-•..ij"��„-*^. -` -
.... • - .:. _. :.y�+7�� uo.3.i:. °':.. �, � '_ .?lir--,v�'��i.aF'-�.�F �.���.�....
'GS'.-.31-oL ' G.. iI; mz'a+•:Y .. r.. -raw.. �' 3'C PJ,i-4�.i-'- *.
Electrical Cade plan Review findings
Reviewed by: Rod foster 33,2-i147 (rfoster@dbs.idaho.gov)
Approved as submitted
T'TIf57SL•�•-•T -�,u.gjy-.g^2jQ �..r
'.•a,�•.�iw�R�.I��YA's��.t�,rv+r �ss..r•S-"J�S��ou-ter--. r e
Mechanical Cade Pian Review Findings
Reviewed by: Russ Owen 332-899G rawera(c-D_dbs.1daho.9aW)
Additional information or correctsians required
I Hnw will aha F,arl, K :�..� _- - --0��_
.. , iV Z1 �rri� «,,, �,%,,,� ,,,y U fE � LoU MPrjd"ce wlin imu tiection bU6 Smoke Detection System
Controls? 1 can not locate any details on the Mechanical plans. SMG Section 606.1 Controls
required. Section 606-.2 Where required. See Exception. Section 606.2.1 Smoke detectors shall
be installed in return air systems with a design capacity greater than 2,000 cfM, in the return duct
or plenum upstream of any filters, exhaust air connections, outdoor air connections, or
decontamination equipment and appliances. Exception: Smoke detectors are not required inreturn air system where a!f partians of the buifding served by the air dis#ribution s stem the
protected by area smoke detectors connected to a dire alarm system in accordance with the
International Fire Code. The smoke detection system shall comply with Section 606.4.
"Building a Safer Idaho "
2. Sheet M1.1 Roams 103 and 104 are restrooms with no separation from the dressing rooms.
Return air may not be taken from rest rooms. See IMC Section 918.6 Prohibited locations.
3. Sheet M1. 1 Heat Pump #4 how is this supplied with OSA?
4. Sheet M1.2 The kiln is a gas appliance which will require combustion air. How will this be
accomplished? Note there is also a 1000 efm exhaust fan shown over the kiln which will need to
be taken into consideration.
5. Sheet M1.4 and M1.5 shows dryer gents which must be 'Installed in accordance with the
manufacturer's installation instructions and IMC Section 504.6. exhaust ducting shall be
round duct with smooth transitions that da not obstruct the flow and cause a lint trap).
6. M1.4 The underground Duct must meet the 20-06 International Energy Conservation Code for
Commercial Structures. Section 503.2.7 Duct and plenum insulation.
All Supply and return ducts and plenums shall be insulated with a minimum of R-5 insulation when
located in unconditioned spaces and with a minimum R-8 insulation when located outside the
building. When located with in a building envelope assembly, the duct or plenum shall be
separated from the building- exterior or unconditioned or exempt spaces by a minimum of R-$
insulation.
Exceptions; When vacated within equipment, when the design temperature deference between the
interior and the exterior of the duct or plenum does not exceeds 15 degrees F.
7. Sheet M1.5 how is Heat pump units 49 and 50 supplied with OSA?
0
S. Sheets M2.1 and CM. I Mechanical rooms how will they be supplied with combustion air as per
I FGC 304-5-
9.
IFGC Section 503.6.9.2 the sizing of gas events for category I1, 1i1, and IV equipment shall be in
accordance with the equipment manufacturer ' s instructions. Have they been consulted about the
venting of these boilers? fete: The maifioided boilers are shown to have an 18 inch exhaust and
so does the single Boiler B-6.
10. Sheet M3.5 but side air requirements. Plans reference statistical data dor alternate antic��ated
occupant load. As an exception to IMC 403,311entilation rate. Please provide fihi's data.
11. Sheet C M 1 - 1 How is OSA provided to FC - 1 , supplying the Weight fitness room?
12. Sheet E.M.1 The air returned from the dust cal�ec#ar can only be allowed in comp�ia�ce with
IMC Section 511.3 As follows, Exhaust system dischairg-we shad be permitted to be recirculated
provided that the sold particulate has been removed at a minimum efficiency of 99.9 percent at 10
microns, vapor concentrations are less than 25 percent of the LFL, and approved equipment is
used to monitor the vapor cancentrate, How will the returned air be in compliance?
13. Sheep EMA. IF�� Hazardous locations Equipment and appliances having an ignition source
sham not be located in Group H occupancies or control areas where open use, handling or
"Building a Safer Idaho 5-f
page 5 of
0
dispensing of combustible, flammable or explosive materials occurs. Hazardous Iocations a
defined in I FGC Section 202, any location considered to be a fire hazard for flammable vapors,
dust, combustible fibers or other highly combustible substance. The Iocation is not necessarily
categorized in the IBC as ahigh-hazard group, The wood shop is an area that has potential of
combustible dust and it also has a spray booth located in it. The unit heaters have an i nition
source and would not be permitted.
14. Sheet EMA Hove will the wood shop be provided with ventilat'I
ion as required by IMC40'�.2? This area does nota � Section
appear to meet natural ventilation. Section 402.
15. Sheet Ei11i.1 The spray room will need to cornpIy with IMS Section 502.7.3.'f Operation.
Mechanical vent�lation shah be kepi in Operation a� a�# Mmes while sprayingoperations are
P being
conducted and for a sufficient time there after to allow vapors from drying coated articles and
finishing material residue to be exhausted. spraying equipment shaft be interlocked with the
ventilation of the spraying area such that spraying operations cannot be conducted unless the
ventilation system is in operation.
Also Section 502.7,x.3 Vetilation systems shall be designed, installed .and maintained such that
the average air velosity over the open face of the booth, or b th cross section in the direction a�
air flow during spraying operations, is not fess than � DD �e�fi peg minute. It would appear thatboath is an open faced unit with a wall and doors builtin front of the booth ? This would the
approval from booth manufacturer for this method of operation toensure adeq.uate require
see SBC and IFC for requirements. air flow.. also
16. Sheet EMA As per IMC 501.3 Pressureequal�za�ion. How will the spay room exhaust be
provided with adequate mans a� ma
dust.. l.e
up air? Note the area also has the exhaust for the woad
17. Sheet EM. 1 IMC Section 5Q2.7.3.6 termination point for exhaust dues shall be vacated
the following. minim -um distances, For ducts conveying explasi�e or flammable ua ars with
dust; 30 feed from a property line; 'f Q feet from openings info the building; � feetps fumes or
and raofs; 34 feet from combus�ible wolfs anc� openings info the buildings. dram exterior walls
applicable dor the spray booth if spray is flammable% This would be
18. Sheet EMA The repair garage will need to comply with 502.14 Motor vehicle operation.
areas where motor vehicles operate, mechanical ventilation shall be required in accordance fn
IMC Section 4Q3. '� with
19, Sheet EM. 1 Metal Shop. Naw will the metal shops exhausts be provided with adeate uof make up air? As per IMC 50�1.3Pressure equaiizatiQn. q means
20. General Cade Sections that may be or may t be �Pplica-ble.
'I . equipment mounted on the roof top including any exhaust fans..
!MG Section 304.10 Guards. Guards shall be placed where appliances, equipment, fcomponents thafi require service are ioca�e� with -in 10 feet of a rood ed or v or other
walking surface and such edge ar apen side is located more than 30 inches��nside v� a
or grade below. The guard shall extend not less thin 3p inches bea above the floor, roof
appliance, equipment, fan or component and the topo� theguard yn���ch end o'€ such
shah be located not leis than 42
"Building a Safer Idaho"
Page 6 of
inches above the elevated surface adjacent to the guard. The guard shall be constructed so as to
prevent the passage of a 21--inch-diameter sphere and shalt comply with the loading requirements
for guards specified in the International Building Gide. If this is applicable provide details showing
�
2. IMC Section 9Q8.3 Location, Cooling tnwPr_czevaporative candUnse�s and T1u�dC1 coolers
located to prevent the d�sc�arg� vapor plumes dram entering occupied spaces. Plume ����1 b�shah be no# less khan 5 fee# above or ��3 feed array from an vee#alaion inletp
r
(Operable windows and doors included).
Y a building.
3. IMC Section 401.5openings. Intake openings. mechanical and gravity outdoor air intake openings shall
bed, located a minimum of 10. feed from any hazardous or noxious contaminant such as vents
chimneys plumbing vents. Where a source of contaminate is iacated within 10 feet of an air intake
opening such opening steall beocated a minimum of 2 feet bellow the contaminate source.
Plumbing Cade Plan Review Findings
Reviewed by: Rusty Boyer 332w8985 (rboyer@dbs.idaho.gov)
Additional inform. tion ar corrections re%iuired
� . The 2" Waste line for laveson BP1 .6 needy to be 311 in the horizontal on both sides of
diagram.
2. The island sink drain upstream shad not service other fixtures, section 909.0 Uniform
Plumbing Dade.
3. Base of stack clean outs for P.-.8's,P34,plO Locker and mechanical rooms.
4. Horizontal drainage piping to be run at 1/419 per foot unless strucfiural conditions existyour
toare limi#ed �172 fixture units at 118th per foot on 4". P-1- 5 tatal fiixture uni#s 188.7
5. All over flow rood drains to be ran down to grade level, as per section 1101 .11 .2.2 18" to
Z4 "s above grade is accep#abbe. P-�3, G" roof drain running to 4" scupper.
G. P-43 in the fixture schedule �s a J R Smith dawn spout not a scupper.
7- Roof Drains are over sized!
8. p-32 P- 1 . 1 1 211 line requires a dean out every 50 " inside a building. per MAPA 07,02.06.17'e
9. hent all P -21's 3" per fixture schedule.
10-.3/4" drain is not dig ena�gh for 1-'� /411 ha�kflow preventer in Nology and chemistry roams.
Elevator �vde Plan Review Findings
Reviewed by-. Gary Barnes 33 -8974 (gbarnes@dbs.idaho.gov)
Approved contingent an the following . IFAAffXAW_
The elevator, the elevator machine room and associated equipment will be subject to the StateIdaho's elewafar prvgr�am including inspections. Carnpliance ►nfith ASMI A17.� ar�d113C
o�
required. the �s
Boiler Code Plan Review Findings
Reviewed by: Mike Paulin 334-7138 (Mpoulin@dbs.idaho.gov)
Approved contingent on the following
""Building a Safer Idaho"
Page 7 of
Boilers, hot water heaters, andpressure vessels shall be installed in accordance with the NBIC
(National Board Inspection Code). This code takes precedence over, all other codes when dealing
with and installing boilers.
`here shall be a minimum of 3 -feet clearance around eachboiler their appurtenances the dap Qfi the boiler. PP ��ances �include
An emergency due[ cit -off switch ds t b located outside the hoofer room.
The owners insurance company's certified and stake commissioned b iler inspecfior shad inspect
this boiler before it is put ire service. �
The boilers shall have a hydrostatic test before being put into service.
The bailer installer shatl provide the Chief Boiler Inspector of Idaho with a copy of the
manufacturers data report,
Bailers shall have a hi9h tempera�u�e cutoff.
Due to the hack of information on these boilers, hod water heatilLn.;Irs-, and pressure vessels thisplanrevr0 ew is lrmited. Failure #v comply with the above req��rements may resulting the shu�dow� of
these items and their removal from service.
Idaho Genera! Safety and Health Standards Plan Review Findings
Reviewed by: Gary Barnes 332-8974 (gbarnes@dbs.l'daho.gov)
Approved contingent on the following
I . Every chemical laboratory shaft be equipped w
meeting the flushing requirements of th S.t
encountered in the laboratory. (7-1-g7)
ith emergency eye wash statians ca pable of
hazardous chemical that could be
2. Every chemical laboratory shall be equipped with an emergency overhead shower
(7-1 Q71
The Idaho General Safely ad Health Standards appfy fa tie design, construction an
bijilding as a auidefine. These standards are not corx�pulsoriJy fora rav�al of � � use of this
annual Safely inspections v�rill include the items listed in this sectio p You 'fie Marrs but the
guideline standards at httD.-11dbs.idaho.,qov1safetv cod�Iindex.f�frnl may access these
... ...�+�•a �s#•�a,a.�... eau„,
Notes:
This plan review reflects the referenced codes as interpreted ,by fhe Division of Buil�'ing Safely. There may be codes
administered by local jurisc�cffons that are different or different interpretations of the same codes. Please
such locaIjurt'sdiction concerningr their requirements. consult
Schaal construction is to be'nspected for code compliance by a certified building ins�ec�or or by an Idahoarchitecf or engr"neer. [!G § 39�47�3� registered
"Building a Saler Idaho,"
Page 8 of
Vince plans are reviewed and approved by the division ofbuildfng safety, no material change can be made to such
plans without review and approval of such charge by the division. Submit two copies of any such granges. [1C 39-
I
4193�4j�' �
7"l�e confraefors perfarmr'rrg fhe work ori fhis prajecf are required to hold a pubJic works contractor license a ro ate
for the hype of work they perform. See httaxIldbs. idaho. ail ublicwork�/cor��ra��ors. hfml der more informai�ion. �
"Building a Safer Idaho "
JUN -27-2008 08:51AM FROM-ENGINEE RFX1-SYSTEMS
June 27, 2008
fir. Brent Me Faflud
JRW & AssociaWs
1152 Bond Avanue
Rexburg, 14aho 53440
Req: Madison High School
Dear Brent'.
208-233-4529
T-001 P.001/002 F-348
9 S Y stems;Inc,
MECHANICAL - ELECTRICAL - ENGINEERING
315 W. CENTER., POCATELLO., IDAHO 83204
TELEPhEC}NE - 208-2ii-mni
FAX - 208-233-0528
D. SUDWFEKS, P.E.
R. RICE, P.Ea
I have recrived the Division of Building Safety Plan Revicw on the subjerl, Ob and w1 address
the co.menTs here:
Plumb* :
Ii
31f waste I icorrected-
2, Isl=d
drains �nsffik,,
&P
Baa of stale clam outs added,
$f In
�+. 4�� ab' mans run at 1/8 T? /ftr Pipc increased to 6` Wherc nee&d on F1.5.
;5, Will drop QveTflow$ to grade where possible ou pl.5.
6. Changed name ro downspouT no2zle.
0
7. Verified all re . f drains �i���Due Lo s�uctu.r� draias slope at 11go/ft.
I oucs aaqea..
" �
�. �ve�coed.Ir10- Drain increased to I".
HVAC-:
I . Smoke, detection added. to Z HVAC systems 9,rearer Th�m 2000 efrn.
2- RetuM ej*rnj�jaje,d from dressing roams 103 & 104 an.d exhaust added here.
3. Ouiside air 4dded to HP, -4
4a Make-up air added to kiln ream and interlocked w�
Allth kilnkilnexhaust pari_
All d�tr vents cb �fed t� ��d, or o�.�t �a� �o �ir�xna�� flow c�bsr.�uu���c��s.
6. u�.���gr�u�'id i��.�tz.l���� �v�ik�. duct ���er.
7, OuEside aix adcled to HP -49 & 50.
S. AR gas appliancfks are sealed. combustion. Combusdou��� d���� added.
9., ManufaQ=e, has been c0nsulMd for boiler fjl"Vsms. Combustion ail- duc�ts a�c��13-6�-� Qe si�e reduced.4. B01 er
MEMBER ACFC
JUN-27-2008
08:52AM FROMmENG I NEERE^
11
208-133-0529 �.y
1
T-001 P-DOZA02 F
Mr. Brent Mc Farland
J4ne 277 2008
Page 2
10. SDistrict was contfacted fir ClISsTOOm SrUdent population. We wi11 get writTen
data from them.
I - Outside ajT d to FC -IT
12. Dust collector manufacturer will provide data on mee�ting IMC 511.30
i3. The unit heaters are sealfad combustion, within the heat exch ger, so no open flame
IF
is cxposcd.to the space, _
14. 100% outd.oar ven�.���o:a added fai- Wood Shap -
1 -5. 100% aaTdaor venulat3an added for Paint BwLh,, and will be IF MerR)cked with PainT
Boorb exhaust fan_
16. Outdoor uui$ provided for me -r -up 41r. Will be slightly less than exhausi fan to kegap
Paint Boat in negative cenditian.
17, Spray)Rooth vxhaust will be vx[endcd ug 10'above roof. Will maintain =nlmam
3•equ1rcd disumces as uoted.
18. Vehicle exh.aus� SYsTem already Showu OTI PIOMS, Make-up air added to rooms
19. 1 % .0 UTdoox air make--4Dadded to W Aar �,g �hA�.
20. a, All roof top aTdr equipment is at Jfast lot frOm any roof edges,
b. Cooling 10werg and caridensMg amrs will be n-jinlraum .5" above or 20' away fTom
4nY Venrilari YntakL
on 4L.
C. Mechanicalintakes will bc rr�inir-num of 10' away froM any plumbing or chimnev
Feel free to cel me if you hav� my questions.
Sincerely.,
F-NGRq1EERFD SYSTEMS ASSOCIATES., ]NC.
Dwayne Sud
IN
eekS