HomeMy WebLinkAboutENGINEER LETTER - 19-00786 - 369 W 3rd S - Solar PanelsDate: December 24, 2019
Big Dog Solar Energy
620 Pheasant Ridge Dr
Chubbuck, ID 83202
Blake Willis Residence: 269 W 3RD S, Rexburg, ID 83440
Dear Sir/ Madam,
Conclusion
Structural Letter of Approval
Terra Engineering Consulting (TEC) has performed a structural analysis for the existing framing
and load conditions and determined that the structure can support the additional load of the
proposed solar panel system. TEC has reviewed the site survey, photographs of the existing
framing, and the proposed PV array. The attached calculations are based off the assumptions that
the existing structural components are in good condition, that they meet industry standards, and
that the site survey provided by the client is accurate. The design assumptions the calculations
are based off are located in the attached References page. The contractor must notify TEC of any
damage to the roof system encountered at the time of installation. The design of the solar panel’s
mounting hardware is to be provided by the manufacturer or installer.
Our conclusions are based off a structural evaluation of the existing framing under the proposed
additional solar panels load. The total load of the solar panels is assumed to not exceed 3 psf,
and the typical 20 psf live load will not be present in the area of the panels, as defined per
Section 1607.12.5 in 2015 IBC. The structural evaluation shows that existing framing is able to
withstand the additional load while meeting current standards, allowing the structure to remain
unaltered; see calculations and span table attached. Regarding lateral loads, the wind load
controls, and due to the low profile of the panels (3” to 6”) as well as PV frame, wiring, conduit ,
and structural component below the module causing restriction in airflow which allow it to be
considered as “partially enclosed structure”; thus the additional pressure on the structure is
considered negligible. The connection hardware is pre-engineered by manufacturer and designed
for metal roofs installations. The addition of total PV system weight result in an increase under
10% of the total roof weight, and meets the seismic requirements in section 403.4 of 2015 IEBC.
TEC concludes that the installation of solar panels on existing roof will not affect the structure of
this residence, and allows it to remain unaltered under the applicable design standards. These
conclusions are based on the attached calculations.
1863 GOLDENROD WAY / NORTH SARATOGA SPRINGS, UT 84045 / T (801)-616-6204
General Instructions
Best Regards,
Terra Engineering Consulting, PLLC
Brice Somers, P.E.
President
Installation and waterproofing must be performed within accepted industry standard.
12/24/2019
1863 GOLDENROD WAY / NORTH SARATOGA SPRINGS, UT 84045 / T (801)-616-6204
References
Design Parameter
Load Combination: ASD
Risk Category: II
Ground Snow load: 50 psf
Roof Snow load: 34.7 psf
Design Wind Speed: 115 mph (3 sec gust) per ASCE 7-10
Seismic Design Category: D
Wind Exposure Category: C
Existing Roof Structure
Roof framing: 2x4 Pre-fab Trusses at 24” O.C.
Roof material: metal seam
Roof slope: 26 °
Roof type: Gable
Solar Panels
(8) Panels
Weight: 3 psf
Code: 2015 International Building Code/ International Existing Building Code, ASCE 7-10, and
National Design Specification for Wood Construction (NDS) 2015 Edition
Connections: Pre-engineered clamps
1863 GOLDENROD WAY / NORTH SARATOGA SPRINGS, UT 84045 / T (801)-616-6204
Date: 12/24/2019
Client: Blake Willis
Subject: Gravity load
Gravity load calculations
Snow load (S)Existing w/ solar panels
Roof slope (°): 26 26
Ground snow load, pg (psf): 50 50 ASCE 7-10, section 7.2
Terrain category: C C ASCE 7-10, table 7-2
Exposure of roof: Fully exposed Fully exposed ASCE 7-10, table 7-2
Exposure factor, Ce: 0.9 0.9 ASCE 7-10, table 7-2
Thermal factor, Ct: 1.1 1.1 ASCE 7-10, table 7-3
Risk Category: II II ASCE 7-10, table 1.5-1
Importance Factor, Is: 1 1 ASCE 7-10, table 1.5-2
Flat roof snow load, pf (psf): 34.7 34.7 ASCE 7-10, equation 7.3-1
Minimum roof snow load, pm (psf): 0 0 ASCE 7-10, equation 7.3-4
Roof Surface type:
Unobstructed
Slippery surface
Unobstructed
slippery surface ASCE 7-10, Section 7.4
Roof slope factor, Cs: 0.73 0.73 ASCE 7-10, figure 7-2b
Sloped roof snow load, ps [psf]: 25.3 25.3
Roof dead load (D)
Roof pitch/12 5.9
metal seam 0.8 psf 1/2" Gypsum clg. 2.2 psf
1/2" plywood 1 psf insulation 0.8 psf
Framing 3 psf M, E & Misc 1.5 psf
Roof DL without PV
arrays 10.3 psf
PV Array DL 3 psf
Roof live load (Lr)Existing w/ solar panels
Roof Live Load 20 0 2015 IBC, Section 1607.12.5
ASD Load combination:
Existing With PV array
D [psf] 10.3 13.3 ASCE 7-10, Section 2.4.1
D+L [psf] 10.3 13.3 ASCE 7-10, Section 2.4.1
D+[Lr or S or R] [psf] 35.6 38.6 ASCE 7-10, Section 2.4.1
29.3 32.3 ASCE 7-10, Section 2.4.1
Maximum gravity load [psf]:35.6 38.6
Max Applied Load (2x4 pre-fab trusses at 24" o.c. 6/12 pitch, 36' span) 38.6 psf
Max Allowable Load (2x4 pre-fab trusses at 24" o.c., 6/12 pitch, 47' span) 47 psf OK
See attached span table
ASCE 7-10, equation 7.4-1, Design
Snow Load (S)
D+0.75L+0.75[Lr or S or R] [psf]
Roof Truss Span Tables
15Alpine Engineered Products
Top Chord 2x4 2x6 2x6 2x4 2x6 2x6 2x4 2x6 2x6 2x4 2x6 2x6
Bottom Chord 2x4 2x4 2x6 2x4 2x4 2x6 2x4 2x4 2x6 2x4 2x4 2x6
2/12 24 24 33 27 27 37 31 31 43 33 33 46
2.5/12 29 29 39 33 33 45 37 38 52 39 40 55
3/12 34 34 46 37 39 53 40 44 60 43 46 64
3.5/12 39 39 53 41 44 61 44 50 65 47 52 70
4/12 41 43 59 43 49 64 46 56 69 49 57 74
5/12 44 52 67* 46 58 69* 49 66 74* 53 66 80*
6/12 46 60* 69* 47 67* 71* 51 74* 76* 55 74* 82*
7/12 47 67* 70* 48* 72* 72* 52* 77* 77* 56* 80* 83*
2/12 24 24 33 25 27 38 27 31 41 29 32 44
2.5/12 28 29 40 29 32 43 31 37 46 33 37 49
3/12 30 33 45 31 37 47 34 42 50 36 42 54
3.5/12 33 37 49* 34 41 51* 36 46 54* 39 46 58*
4/12 35 41 52* 36 45* 54* 39 50* 58* 42* 49* 62*
‡ Other pitch combinations available with these spans
For Example, a 5/12 - 2/12 combination has approx. the same allowable span as a 6/12 - 3/12
Top Chord 2x4 2x6 2x6 2x4 2x6 2x6 2x4 2x6 2x6 2x4 2x6 2x6
Bottom Chord 2x4 2x4 2x6 2x4 2x4 2x6 2x4 2x4 2x6 2x4 2x4 2x6
16" 23 24 25 § 25 § 25 § 25 § 25 § 25 § 25 § 25 § 25 § 25 §
18" 25 27 28 27 27 29 § 29 § 29 § 29 § 29 § 29 § 29 §
20" 27 28 30 28 28 32 31 30 33 § 32 31 33 §
24" 29 30 33 31 31 35 34 33 38 35 34 40
28" 32 32 36 34 33 39 37 36 42 38 37 44
30" 33 33 38 35 35 40 38 37 44 40 39 45
32" 34 34 39 36 36 42 39 39 45 41 40 47
36" 36 36 42 39 38 45 42 41 48 43 43 50
42" 39 39 45 41 41 48 44 44 52 45 46 54
48" 40 42 49 43 44 52 46 47 56 46 49 58
60" 44 47 55 46 49 58 48 53 63 49 55 65
72" 45 51 60 48 54 64 51 57 68 51 59 69
§ = Span Limited by length to depth ratio of 24
Pitch
Depth
Spans in feet to out of bearing
Spans in feet to out of bearing
5/12 38* 47* 57* 39* 51* 59* 42* 56* 63* 45* 54* 68*
6/12 - 2/12 ‡ 40 43 59* 42 49 62* 45 56* 66 48 57* 71*
6/12 - 2.5/12 ‡ 37 38 52 38 44 57* 41 50 61* 44 52 66*
6/12 - 3/12 ‡ 33 33 45 35 38 52 38 43 56* 40 46 60*
6/12 - 3.5/12 ‡ 28 28 38 32 32 44 34 37 50 36 39 54
6/12 - 4/12 ‡ 22 22 31 26 26 36 30 30 41 32 32 44
Alpine truss designs are
engineered to meet specific
span, configuration and load
conditions. The shapes and
spans shown here represent
only a fraction of the
millions of designs produced
by Alpine engineers.
Total load(PSF)
Duration factor
Live load(PSF)
Roof type
55
1.15
40 snow
shingle
55
1.15
30 snow
tile
47
1.15
30 snow
shingle
40
1.15
20 snow
shingle
40
1.25
20 **
shingle
**construction
or rain,
not snow load
55
1.15
40 snow
47
1.15
30 snow
40
1.15
20 snow
40
1.25
20 rain or constn.
Total load(PSF)
Duration factor
Live load(PSF)
NOTES:These overall spans are based on NDS
‘01 with 4" nominal bearing each end, 24" o.c.
spacing, a live load deflection limited to L/240
maximum and use lumber properties as follows:
2x4f =2000psif=1100psiE=1.8x10 2x6f =1750
psi f=950 psi f =1900 psi E=1.8x10 . Allowable
spans for 2x4 top chord trusses using sheathing
other than plywood (e.g. spaced sheathing or 1x
boards) may be reduced slightly. Trusses must
be designed for any special loading such as
concentrated loads from hanging partitions or air
conditioning units, and snow loads caused by
driftingnearparapetorslide-offfromhigherroofs.
To achieve maximum indicated spans, trusses
may require six or more panels. Trusses with an
asterisk (*) that exceed 14' in height may be
shipped in two pieces. Contact your local Alpine
trussmanufacturerorofficeformoreinformation.
bt b
tc
6
6
Common --Truss configurations for the
most widely designed roof shapes.
Mono --Used where the roof is required to
slope only in one direction. Also in pairs
with their high ends abutting on
extremely long spans with a
support underneath
the high end.
Scissors --Provides a cathedral or
vaulted ceiling. Most economical when the
difference in slope between the top and
bottom chords is at least 3/12 or the bottom
chord pitch is no more than half the top chord
pitch.
Flat --The most economical flat truss for a
roof is provided when the depth of the truss in
inches is approximately equal to 7% of the
span in inches.